I
began election night writing a column that started with words from an
immigrant, my friend Lesley Goldwasser, who came to America from
Zimbabwe in the 1980s. Surveying our political scene a few years ago,
Lesley remarked to me: “You Americans kick around your country like it’s
a football. But it’s not a football. It’s a FabergĂ© egg. You can break
it.”
With
Donald Trump now elected president, I have more fear than I’ve ever had
in my 63 years that we could do just that — break our country, that we
could become so irreparably divided that our national government will
not function.
From
the moment Trump emerged as a candidate, I’ve taken seriously the
possibility that he could win; this column never predicted otherwise,
although it certainly wished for it. That doesn’t mean the reality of it
is not shocking to me.
As
much as I knew that it was a possibility, the stark fact that a
majority of Americans wanted radical, disruptive change so badly and
simply did not care who the change agent was, what sort of role model he
could be for our children, whether he really had any ability to execute
on his plan — or even really had a plan to execute on — is profoundly
disturbing.
Before
I lay out all my fears, is there any silver lining to be found in this
vote? I’ve been searching for hours, and the only one I can find is
this: I don’t think Trump was truly committed to a single word or policy
he offered during the campaign, except one phrase: “I want to win.”
But
Donald Trump cannot be a winner unless he undergoes a radical change in
personality and politics and becomes everything he was not in this
campaign. He has to become a healer instead of a divider; a compulsive
truth-teller rather than a compulsive liar; someone ready to study
problems and make decisions based on evidence, not someone who just
shoots from the hip; someone who tells people what they need to hear,
not what they want to hear; and someone who appreciates that an
interdependent world can thrive only on win-win relationships, not
zero-sum ones.
I
can only hope that he does. Because if he doesn’t, all of you who voted
for him — overlooking all of his obvious flaws — because you wanted
radical, disruptive change, well, you’re going to get it.
I
assume that Trump will not want to go down as the worst president in
history, let alone the one who presided over the deepest fracturing of
our country since the Civil War. It would shake the whole world.
Therefore, I can only hope that he will, as president, seek to surround
himself with the best people he can, which surely doesn’t include the
likes of Rudy Giuliani or Newt Gingrich, let alone the alt-right
extremists who energized his campaign.
But
there is also a deeply worrying side to Trump’s obsession with
“winning.” For him, life is always a zero-sum game: I win, you lose. But
when you’re running the United States of America, everything can’t be a
zero-sum game.
“The
world only stays stable when countries are embedded in win-win
relationships, in healthy interdependencies,” observed Dov Seidman, the
C.E.O. of LRN, which advises companies on leadership, and the author of
the book “How.”
For
instance, America undertook the Marshall Plan after World War II —
giving millions of dollars to Europe — to build it up into a trading
partner and into a relationship that turned out to be of great mutual
benefit. Does Trump understand that? Do those who voted for him
understand how many of their jobs depend on America being embedded in
healthy interdependencies around the world?
How
do I explain Trump’s victory? Way too soon to say for sure, but my gut
tells me that it has much less to do with trade or income gaps and much
more to do with culture and many Americans’ feeling of “homelessness.”
There
is nothing that can make people more angry or disoriented than feeling
they have lost their home. For some it is because America is becoming a
minority-majority country and this has threatened the sense of community
of many middle-class whites, particularly those living outside the more
cosmopolitan urban areas.
For
others it is the dizzying whirlwind of technological change we’re now
caught up in. It has either wiped out their job or transformed their
workplace in ways they find disorienting — or has put stressful demands
on them for lifelong learning. When the two most important things in
your life are upended — the workplace and community that anchor you and
give you identity — it’s not surprising that people are disoriented and
reach for the simplistic solutions touted by a would-be strongman.
What
I do know for certain is this: The Republican Party and Donald Trump
will have control of all the levers of government, from the courts to
the Congress to the White House. That is an awesome responsibility, and
it is all going to be on them. Do they understand that?
Personally,
I will not wish them ill. Too much is at stake for my country and my
children. Unlike the Republican Party for the last eight years, I am not
going to try to make my president fail. If he fails, we all fail. So
yes, I will hope that a better man emerges than we saw in this campaign.
But
at the moment I am in anguish, frightened for my country and for our
unity. And for the first time, I feel homeless in America.
Follow The New York Times Opinion section on Facebook and Twitter (@NYTopinion), and sign up for the Opinion Today newsletter.
No comments:
Post a Comment